Heritage Home on Queen Street Niagara-on-the-Lake For Sale

All Photos courtesy Andrew Perrie, Revel Realty Inc.

Two hours from Toronto and just 20 minutes from the Rainbow Bridge border crossing to the United States, Niagara-on-the-Lake continues to command attention from discerning homebuyers across Ontario.

Established as Newark way back in 1792 and briefly serving as Upper Canada‘s first capital, NOTL remains one of Canada‘s most desirable addresses. With the Shaw Festival Theatre attracting over 250,000 visitors annually and the region’s 40-plus wineries generating billions in tourism revenue, property values in Old Town Niagara-on-the-Lake have climbed steadily, with heritage homes fetching the kind of prices that rival the GTA’s most exclusive neighbourhoods like Oakville.

Exterior with swim pool — *The home’s property is large enough for expansion*

Queen Street in particular stands out as the top spot for Niagara-on-the-Lake real estate. Running through the heart of Old Town from Fort George National Historic Site to Simcoe Park, this tree-lined boulevard has housed the town’s most prominent families since the early 1800s. Today, a Queen Street address signals not just success but an appreciation for architectural heritage.

Home on Queen Street Niagara-on-the-Lake for Sale

This exquisite property at 166 Queen Street exemplifies everything the discerning buyer seeks in premium NOTL real estate. Built in 1912 during the town’s Edwardian building boom, this nearly 4,000-square-foot residence occupies an exceptional 112 x 253-foot lot that provides complete privacy while remaining walking distance to the town’s famous clock tower at the corner of Queen and King Streets.

The main residence spans five bedrooms across multiple levels, with original hardwood floors running throughout the principal rooms. The formal dining room easily accommodates up to 12 guests, while the family room features period millwork and oversized windows that flood the space with natural light. The home office, configured as a library with built-in shelving, overlooks the property’s mature trees and offers a quiet retreat for remote work or reading.

Spacious kitchen at Heritage Home on Queen Street Niagara-on-the-Lake — *This NOTL heritage Home features two kitchens*

Enjoy cooking? Two fully equipped kitchens provide exceptional flexibility for hosting and daily living. The main kitchen maintains the home’s period character while incorporating modern appliances and ample counter space. The second kitchen, part of the self-contained nanny quarters, includes its own entrance and could function as a rental suite, generating income from visiting Shaw Festival performers or wine tourists seeking short-term accommodations in Old Town NOTL.

Luxury House for Sale in Niagara-on-the-Lake

Outside, the property reveals its true scope. The new wood deck stretches across the rear of the home, providing space for a full outdoor dining set and lounge furniture. The in-ground pool, positioned for maximum sun exposure, includes a surrounding patio area that easily accommodates poolside entertaining. Mature plantings create natural privacy screens, making the backyard feel like a private resort despite its central location.

The upper-level balcony offers complete seclusion, ideal for morning coffee or evening wine while watching horse-drawn carriages pass along Queen Street. The lot’s substantial size means there’s room for additional structures if desired, with several comparable NOTL properties adding coach houses or studio spaces to maximize their land use.

NOTL home hallway — *The home features original 1912 hardwood floors*

Year-round maintenance has been meticulous, from the preserved exterior trim work to the updated mechanicals. The basement provides extensive storage and workshop space, addressing a common limitation in heritage properties. Multiple heating zones ensure comfort across all seasons, particularly important given Niagara’s humid summers and lake-effect winters.

Getting Down to Business

Looking for a new location for your business? The property’s commercial zoning adds another dimension to its appeal.

Professional services such as dental practices, accounting firms, and chiropractic clinics are permitted uses, making 166 Queen Street attractive to entrepreneurs seeking a prestigious business address. Several Queen Street properties already operate as boutique offices, capitalizing on the street’s high visibility and foot traffic from the thousands of tourists who stroll past daily during peak season.

Whatever your desired use of this charming property, 166 Queen Street puts you minutes from Niagara-on-the-Lake Golf Club, while the Shaw Festival’s four theatres stage productions from April through December. Wine enthusiasts can reach places like Peller Estates in a few minutes by car, while Jackson-Triggs, Stratus, and Inniskillin are nearby.