Photo courtesy Sterling Inn & Spa
Updated Aug 29, 2023 / Commissions may be earned from our affiliate partner links
Niagara Falls, Canada’s most breathtaking natural wonder, draws millions of people every year. But beyond the falls, the city is also home to a number of unique and boutique hotels that offer visitors an unforgettable stay.
From historic inns set in old mansions and townhomes to modern hotels featuring quirky themes and designs, the accommodations available at these destinations offer something for every traveller looking for a more modest luxury experience.
Read our list of the best unique and boutique hotels in Niagara Falls to learn more about some of the region’s most memorable places to stay.
Unique & Boutique Hotels in Niagara Falls
Old Stone Inn Boutique Hotel
Located in the heart of Niagara Falls, the Old Stone Inn Boutique Hotel is a historic hotel that dates back to 1904. The hotel features 37 unique guest rooms and suites, each of which is decorated with antique furnishings and modern amenities. Some of the rooms even feature wood-burning fireplaces, perfect for a cozy night in for couples enjoying a romantic getaway to Niagara Falls.
One of our favorite luxury hotels in Niagara Falls, the Old Stone’s restaurant, the Flour Mill Scratch Kitchen, is a local favorite, serving up delicious farm-to-table cuisine using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. The hotel also offers a variety of packages, including a romance package featuring a three-course dinner for two, a bottle of wine, and a romantic rose petal turndown service.
LuxuryNiagaraFalls Recommends: For the latest info and rates, and to make reservations, visit Old Stone Inn Boutique Hotel
Sterling Inn & Spa
The 4-star Sterling Inn & Spa is a luxury boutique hotel located just a few blocks from Niagara Falls. The hotel features 41 elegant guest rooms, each of which is designed to provide maximum comfort and relaxation. The rooms feature king-size beds, whirlpool tubs, and fireplaces, creating a cozy and intimate atmosphere.
The hotel’s spa is one of its biggest draws and offers a range of treatments designed to soothe body and soul. The spa area also features a heated indoor pool, a sauna, a steam room, and a fitness center, providing you with everything needed to unwind and relax.
LuxuryNiagaraFalls Recommends: For the latest info and rates, and to make reservations, visit Sterling Inn & Spa
Stone Mill Inn
The Stone Mill Inn is set in a beautifully restored 1800s mill located just a few minutes from Niagara Falls in neighboring St Catharines. This great 3-star hotel features 34 spacious guest rooms, each with comfortable king beds, whirlpool tubs, and fireplaces.
Be sure to book a table at the hotel’s first-rate restaurant, Johnny Roccos Italian Grill. As popular with locals as it is guests, this great Niagara Falls restaurant serves up delicious Italian cuisine using fresh, locally sourced ingredients. In-room and private dining packages are available.
LuxuryNiagaraFalls Recommends: For the latest info and rates, and to make reservations at one of the best boutique hotels in Niagara Falls region, visit Stone Mill Inn
The Woodbourne Inn is a beautiful 1839 mansion located just a few minutes from all the fun of the falls. This luxe 4-star inn features just six elegant guest rooms, each of which is decorated with antique furnishings and classy décor.
High-end beds and bedding are standard, as are the spacious bathrooms with whirlpool tubs. They also come with cozy fireplaces.
LuxuryNiagaraFalls Recommends: For the latest info and rates, and to make reservations, visit Woodbourne Inn
Butterfly Manor is a charming bed and breakfast inn located close to the main points of interest in Niagara Falls. The inn features four beautifully appointed guest rooms, each of which is decorated with a butterfly theme and features queen-size beds and private bathrooms.
Had a hard day exploring Niagara? You’ll enjoy relaxing in the inn’s quaint garden, a tranquil oasis that’s perfect for unwinding after a long day of exploring Niagara Falls. In addition to being home to a variety of plants, flowers, and yes, even butterflies, the garden also boasts a pond and waterfall.
Butterfly Manor also offers a delicious breakfast every morning, featuring homemade baked goods and fresh fruit.
LuxuryNiagaraFalls Recommends: For the latest info and rates, and to make reservations, visit Butterfly Manor
Serene Niagara Inn
A peaceful retreat located just a few minutes away from the falls, Serene Niagara Inn certainly lives up to its name. The inn features just four spacious guest rooms, each providing maximum comfort and relaxation with king beds and spacious bathrooms.
The inn’s garden is a peaceful oasis, perfect for relaxing after a long day of exploring Niagara Falls. A great breakfast is provided, and a large garden is available for you to relax in.
LuxuryNiagaraFalls Recommends: For the latest info and rates, and to make reservations, visit Serene Niagara Inn
A Night to Remember
The aptly named A Night to Remember is a romantic Niagara Falls B&B that features four elegantly appointed guest rooms. In addition to being decorated with a romantic theme, each features a king bed, whirlpool tub, and fireplace.
A delicious breakfast is provided each morning of your stay and features homemade baked goods and fresh fruit.
LuxuryNiagaraFalls Recommends: For the latest info and rates, and to make reservations, visit A Night to Remember
Cadillac Motel is one for car fans wanting something classy yet fun. This self-proclaimed “retro-chic” boutique hotel is located close to many of the best things to do in Niagara Falls and features 32 spacious guest rooms. While the rooms are perhaps a little simpler than those at some of the other boutique hotels on this list, they’re clean, comfortable… and Cadillac-themed.
The motel also features a heated outdoor pool, perfect for a refreshing dip after a long day of exploring Niagara Falls. The motel’s location is also a big draw, as it’s just a short walk from the falls and many of the city’s top attractions.
LuxuryNiagaraFalls Recommends: For the latest info and rates, and to make reservations, visit Cadillac Motel
While located on the New York side of the Niagara River, The Giacomo Hotel had to be included on this list as it’s our favorite luxury hotel in Niagara Falls NY. This 4-star luxury boutique hotel is located just a short distance from the American Falls and boasts 44 beautifully appointed guest rooms, each with a king-size bed, separate bathrooms, and cozy fireplaces.
The hotel’s upper-level Skyview Lounge offers stunning views of Niagara Falls and the surrounding area. The hotel’s staff can make arrangements for in-room treats and drinks, as well as reservations at nearby restaurants.
LuxuryNiagaraFalls Recommends: For the latest info and rates, and to make reservations, visit The Giacomo
Kim Kerr is a Co-founder of Riley and a fan of luxury travel.